Best Transportation Management: Ranked and Reviewed (2024)

Did you know that effective Transportation Management can reduce logistics costs by up to 20%?

In today’s fast-paced business environment, efficient Transportation Management is crucial for companies looking to optimize their supply chain operations. With the right Transportation Management software solutions, businesses can streamline their logistics processes, improve customer satisfaction, and ultimately save significant costs.

Key Takeaways:

  • Effective Transportation Management can reduce logistics costs by up to 20%.
  • Transportation Management software solutions optimize supply chain operations.
  • Streamlining logistics processes improves customer satisfaction.
  • Using the right software solutions leads to significant cost savings.
  • Stay tuned for our rankings and reviews of the top Transportation Management companies.

The Importance of Transportation Management Systems

A Transportation Management System (TMS) is crucial for businesses seeking to improve their logistics operations. It provides solutions for efficient and effective transportation management, including planning, execution, tracking, and settlement of shipments.

By using a TMS, businesses can streamline their supply chain, reduce costs, and improve customer satisfaction. Efficient transportation management systems allow for optimized route planning, load optimization, and real-time visibility, enabling businesses to make data-driven decisions and respond promptly to changes in demand or disruptions in the supply chain.

Effective transportation management services help businesses achieve faster and more reliable deliveries, reducing transit times, increasing on-time performance, and minimizing delays or errors. With advanced features such as automated freight tendering, carrier selection, and freight audit, businesses can enhance their operational efficiency and ensure compliance with transportation regulations.

Implementing a robust transportation management system can transform a business’s logistics operations, bringing increased visibility, cost savings, and improved customer service. It is a strategic investment that can propel a company ahead of its competition in today’s fast-paced and dynamic business landscape.

The Benefits of Transportation Management Systems

There are several key benefits that businesses can enjoy by leveraging efficient transportation management systems:

  • Streamlined Supply Chain: A TMS optimizes the movement of goods, enabling businesses to reduce transportation costs, minimize shipping errors, and optimize inventory levels.
  • Improved Visibility: Real-time tracking and monitoring capabilities offered by TMS solutions allow businesses to have complete visibility into their transportation operations, reducing delays and enhancing customer service.
  • Reduced Transportation Costs: Efficient route planning, load consolidation, and carrier selection capabilities help businesses optimize their transportation spend and negotiate better rates with carriers.
  • Enhanced Customer Service: By improving delivery times, reducing transit times, and providing accurate and timely information about shipments, businesses can enhance their customer service, leading to increased customer satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Proactive Issue Resolution: TMS solutions enable businesses to identify potential issues and bottlenecks in the transportation process before they become significant problems, allowing for proactive problem-solving and minimizing disruptions.
  • Data-Driven Decision Making: TMS platforms generate valuable data and analytics that can be used to identify trends, patterns, and opportunities for improvement, enabling businesses to make data-driven decisions and continuously optimize their transportation operations.

By leveraging efficient transportation management systems, businesses can unlock these benefits and gain a competitive edge in today’s challenging business landscape.

Top Transportation Management System Providers

When it comes to reliable and affordable Transportation Management solutions, there are several top providers in the market. These providers offer a wide range of features and capabilities to meet the transportation management needs of businesses of all sizes. Let’s take a look at some of the leading providers:

  1. e2open: e2open provides comprehensive transportation management systems that cater to shippers, freight forwarders, carriers, and logistics service providers. Their TMS offers solutions for both domestic and international logistics, making it suitable for businesses with diverse transportation requirements.
  2. Descartes: Descartes offers a stand-alone TMS and managed TM services. Their TMS provides robust capabilities for both domestic and international freight modes. It is an ideal choice for shippers and third-party logistics companies seeking efficient transportation management services.
  3. Blue Yonder: Blue Yonder is the largest independent SCM suite vendor, specializing in solutions for large complex shippers and 3PLs. Their TMS is designed to handle global supply chain requirements, providing a comprehensive platform for transportation management.
  4. Manhattan: Manhattan has a strong history in transportation management and integrates its TMS seamlessly with their supply chain applications. Primarily offered as an add-on solution to their Warehouse Management System (WMS), Manhattan’s TMS is known for its WMS integration capabilities.
  5. MercuryGate: MercuryGate primarily serves the North American market with its robust TMS. It caters to companies of all sizes and supports both domestic and international modes of freight. MercuryGate offers competitive cost of ownership, making it an attractive option for businesses seeking affordable transportation management solutions.
  6. Oracle: Oracle’s TMS is designed for medium and large complex shippers and 3PLs. It integrates well with their ERP and SCM software, providing a comprehensive platform for global supply chain requirements. However, the TCO for Oracle TMS is higher compared to other platforms.
  7. SAP: SAP’s TMS offers robust transportation management capabilities, with integration to their ERP and SCM software. It caters to medium and large complex shippers and 3PLs, providing solutions for global supply chain requirements. SAP partners with Descartes for carrier communication functionality.
  8. TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson: TMC offers a robust TMS that supports all modes of domestic and international freight. They also provide managed TM services, focusing on medium to large shippers. TMC’s pricing structure can be complex, requiring thorough evaluation before making a decision.
  9. Trimble: Trimble’s TMS specializes in supporting non-asset and internal fleet operations. While primarily focused on the North American market, Trimble offers robust solutions for transportation management, catering to both shippers and 3PLs.
  10. Uber Freight TMS: Uber Freight TMS, formerly known as Transplace, provides both managed TM and standalone TMS options. It offers comprehensive capabilities for both North American and international freight, making it an attractive choice for medium to large shippers. The reported TCO is relatively competitive.

These reliable Transportation Management providers offer affordable Transportation Management solutions that businesses can leverage to optimize their logistics operations and streamline their supply chain. Whether you require a solution for domestic or international logistics, there is a TMS provider on this list that can cater to your specific needs.

e2open

As a leading provider of transportation management systems, e2open offers comprehensive solutions for all modes and regions of transportation, both domestically and internationally. Their transportation management system (TMS) is designed to cater to the needs of shippers, freight forwarders, carriers, and logistics service providers (LSPs).

With e2open’s TMS, businesses can effectively manage their domestic and international logistics operations. The system provides robust functionalities to optimize transportation planning, execution, tracking, and settlement. Whether it’s managing road, rail, air, or sea transportation, e2open’s TMS is equipped to handle it all.

One of the key strengths of e2open’s TMS is its ability to integrate seamlessly with other supply chain systems and processes. This allows for efficient information flow and collaboration across the entire supply chain, leading to better decision-making and improved operational performance.

“e2open’s TMS provides a comprehensive and user-friendly solution for managing transportation operations. Its ability to handle both domestic and international logistics makes it a valuable tool for businesses operating in a global marketplace.”

e2open’s TMS offers a range of features and capabilities that enable businesses to optimize their transportation operations. Some of the key benefits include:

  • Efficient route planning and optimization
  • Real-time shipment tracking and visibility
  • Automated freight tendering and carrier selection
  • Accurate freight cost calculation and billing
  • Effective management of transportation contracts and rates
  • Streamlined collaboration with partners and stakeholders

By leveraging e2open’s TMS, businesses can achieve cost savings, improve delivery reliability, enhance customer service, and gain a competitive edge in the market.

Key Features Benefits
Efficient route planning and optimization Cost savings through optimized transportation routes
Real-time shipment tracking and visibility Improved agility and responsiveness in logistics operations
Automated freight tendering and carrier selection Enhanced efficiency in sourcing and selecting transportation providers
Accurate freight cost calculation and billing Reduced billing errors and improved financial accuracy
Effective management of transportation contracts and rates Optimized contract compliance and improved cost control
Streamlined collaboration with partners and stakeholders Improved visibility and communication across the supply chain

Descartes

Descartes is a highly regarded provider of transportation management solutions. They offer a stand-alone TMS as well as managed TM services to meet the diverse needs of businesses in the logistics industry. With their robust TMS, Descartes provides comprehensive capabilities for both domestic and international freight modes, catering to shippers and third-party logistics companies (3PLs) alike.

Descartes’ stand-alone TMS is a powerful tool that enables businesses to efficiently manage and optimize their transportation operations. It offers a wide range of features and functionalities, including real-time tracking, route optimization, freight consolidation, and carrier selection. These capabilities help businesses streamline their supply chain processes, reduce costs, and enhance customer satisfaction.

With Descartes’ managed TM services, businesses can benefit from expert assistance in managing their transportation needs. Descartes’ team of professionals takes care of the entire transportation management process, allowing businesses to focus on their core competencies. From carrier selection and rate negotiation to freight auditing and invoice processing, Descartes’ managed TM services provide end-to-end solutions for businesses seeking to outsource their transportation management.

Descartes stands out in the transportation management market, offering a combination of a stand-alone TMS and managed TM services. This gives businesses the flexibility to choose the approach that best fits their needs. Whether businesses prefer to manage their transportation operations internally or outsource it to Descartes’ experts, they can rely on Descartes to deliver reliable and efficient solutions.

Descartes’ total cost of ownership (TCO) is competitive, making their TMS an attractive option for businesses of all sizes. Their pricing structure is transparent, with no hidden fees or unexpected costs. Descartes’ flexible licensing options further contribute to their affordability, allowing businesses to scale their TMS usage based on their specific requirements and budget.

Descartes has established itself as a trusted partner in the transportation management industry, serving a wide range of customers across different sectors. Their commitment to innovation, customer satisfaction, and excellence has earned them a strong reputation in the market. By choosing Descartes’ stand-alone TMS or leveraging their managed TM services, businesses can optimize their transportation operations and gain a competitive edge in today’s dynamic logistics landscape.

Blue Yonder

Blue Yonder is a renowned SCM suite vendor, offering comprehensive solutions for global supply chain requirements. As the largest independent vendor in the market, Blue Yonder specializes in providing Transportation Management Systems (TMS) that cater to large complex shippers and third-party logistics providers (3PLs).

Their TMS is equipped with robust capabilities to handle the complexities of the global supply chain, ensuring efficient and streamlined transportation operations. With Blue Yonder’s TMS, businesses can effectively manage their logistics and meet the demands of today’s dynamic marketplace.

However, it’s important to note that choosing Blue Yonder’s TMS comes with a higher total cost of ownership (TCO) compared to other TMS platforms. While the initial investment may be higher, the value and capabilities offered by Blue Yonder’s TMS make it a compelling choice for companies aiming to optimize their transportation management processes.

Key Features of Blue Yonder TMS:

  • Advanced route optimization for efficient shipment planning and execution
  • Real-time visibility into shipments for enhanced tracking and monitoring
  • Carrier management capabilities for effective collaboration with transportation partners
  • Integrated analytics and reporting for data-driven decision-making and performance measurement
  • Seamless integration with other supply chain systems for end-to-end visibility and efficiency

With its comprehensive features and commitment to meeting global supply chain requirements, Blue Yonder stands out as a leading choice for businesses seeking a robust and scalable transportation management solution.

Blue Yonder’s TMS empowers companies to effectively navigate the complexities of the global supply chain, optimize transportation operations, and drive business growth.

Vendor Target Market Key Strengths Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Blue Yonder Large complex shippers, 3PLs Robust capabilities, global supply chain focus Higher
E2open Shippers, freight forwarders, carriers, LSPs Comprehensive solutions, all modes and regions Varies
Descartes Shippers, 3PLs Stand-alone TMS, managed TM services Varies
Manhattan Shippers, 3PLs WMS integration, add-on solution Relatively high

Manhattan

Manhattan has established a strong reputation in the field of transportation management. Their Transportation Management System (TMS) seamlessly integrates with their supply chain applications, offering a comprehensive solution for businesses.

One of the key advantages of Manhattan’s TMS is its integration with their Warehouse Management System (WMS). This integration allows for efficient coordination between transportation and warehouse operations, optimizing the overall supply chain. The TMS is often offered as an add-on solution to enhance the functionality of the WMS, providing businesses with a seamless end-to-end solution.

While Manhattan’s TMS and WMS integration offer significant benefits, it is important to consider the total cost of ownership (TCO). Compared to other TMS platforms, the TCO for Manhattan’s solution may be relatively high. However, the added value and streamlined processes enabled by the integration can justify the investment for many businesses.

If you are looking for a transportation management solution that seamlessly integrates with your warehouse operations, Manhattan’s TMS with WMS integration and add-on solution is worth considering. It provides a holistic approach to managing your supply chain, optimizing efficiency and enhancing overall performance.

Note: The image above showcases the seamless integration between Manhattan’s TMS and their Warehouse Management System (WMS).

MercuryGate

MercuryGate is a leading provider of Transportation Management System (TMS) solutions, primarily focused on serving the North American market. With its robust TMS platform, MercuryGate caters to companies of all sizes, offering support for both domestic and international modes of freight.

One of the key advantages of choosing MercuryGate is its competitive cost of ownership. The company continuously enhances its capabilities, providing cost-effective transportation management solutions that deliver value to its customers.

MercuryGate’s TMS is specifically designed to meet the needs of various stakeholders in the logistics industry, including 3PLs, brokers, shippers, and private fleet companies. Its North American orientation ensures that businesses operating in this region can efficiently manage their transportation operations and optimize their supply chain.

By leveraging MercuryGate’s TMS, companies can streamline their logistics processes, improve visibility and control, reduce transportation costs, and enhance customer satisfaction. With its comprehensive features and customer-centric approach, MercuryGate is a trusted partner for optimizing transportation management.

Oracle

In the realm of transportation management systems, Oracle offers a robust solution specifically designed to meet the needs of medium and large complex shippers as well as third-party logistics providers (3PLs). Their TMS comes equipped with powerful capabilities designed to handle global supply chain requirements seamlessly. Moreover, Oracle’s TMS integrates seamlessly with their ERP and SCM software, enabling businesses to achieve a more holistic approach to transportation management.

With Oracle’s TMS, complex shippers can effectively optimize their supply chain operations, streamline processes, and enhance overall efficiency. This comprehensive solution caters to the unique demands of global businesses, ensuring smooth logistics operations across borders and continents. By leveraging Oracle’s TMS, companies can achieve better visibility, cost control, and customer satisfaction.

However, it’s essential to note that the total cost of ownership (TCO) for Oracle’s TMS is relatively higher compared to other platforms. Businesses considering implementing Oracle’s TMS should carefully evaluate their budget and long-term goals to make an informed decision. Despite the higher TCO, the robust capabilities and integration with Oracle’s ERP and SCM software make it a compelling choice for organizations with significant global supply chain requirements.

“Oracle’s TMS is a powerful solution for businesses with complex supply chain needs. Its seamless integration with Oracle’s ERP and SCM software ensures a comprehensive approach to transportation management. Although the TCO may be higher, the benefits of enhanced efficiency and global supply chain optimization make it a worthwhile investment.”

SAP

In today’s global marketplace, businesses face complex challenges when it comes to managing their supply chains. Effective integration of SAP, ERP, and SCM software is a key factor in optimizing operations and meeting global supply chain requirements.

As a leading provider of enterprise software solutions, SAP offers a robust Transportation Management System (TMS) that seamlessly integrates with their ERP and SCM software. This integration allows businesses to streamline their transportation processes, improve visibility, and enhance overall efficiency.

The SAP TMS is designed to cater to the needs of medium and large complex shippers as well as third-party logistics providers (3PLs). It provides comprehensive capabilities to handle global supply chain requirements, including planning, execution, tracking, and settlement of shipments.

One notable aspect of SAP’s TMS is its partnership with Descartes for carrier communication functionality. This collaboration enhances the communication and collaboration between shippers and carriers, enabling a seamless transportation experience.

Benefits of SAP’s TMS:
  • Efficient integration with ERP and SCM software
  • Enhanced visibility and control over transportation operations
  • Improved collaboration with carriers
  • Streamlined planning, execution, tracking, and settlement of shipments
  • Ability to handle complex global supply chain requirements

While SAP’s TMS offers extensive functionality and benefits, it is important to consider the total cost of ownership (TCO) associated with implementing and maintaining the system. The TCO for SAP TMS is relatively high, which may impact the decision-making process for some businesses.

SAP TMS

By leveraging SAP’s TMS and its integration with ERP and SCM software, businesses can achieve end-to-end visibility, optimize their transportation processes, and effectively meet global supply chain requirements. However, it is crucial for businesses to carefully evaluate their specific needs, budget, and long-term goals before making a decision.

TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson

When it comes to robust Transportation Management Systems (TMS) and managed TM services, TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson stands out as a trusted provider in the industry. Their comprehensive TMS supports all modes of domestic and international freight, making it suitable for businesses with diverse transportation needs.

TMC goes beyond offering a reliable TMS by also providing managed TM services. With a focus on medium to large shippers, TMC’s expertise in managing transportation operations can help businesses streamline their supply chain and achieve greater efficiencies.

However, it is worth noting that TMC’s pricing structure can be complex. Thorough vetting is necessary to understand the costs involved and ensure the solution aligns with your budget and requirements.

Overall, TMC offers a mid to high range TCO, reflecting the robustness and value of their TMS and managed TM services.

For businesses seeking a trustworthy partner for their transportation management needs, TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson is a strong contender. Their robust TMS and managed TM services can drive operational excellence and support the growth of medium to large shippers.

TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson Key Features
Robust TMS Supports all modes of domestic and international freight
Managed TM Services Expertise in managing transportation operations
Pricing Structure Mid to high range TCO

Trimble

When it comes to efficient non-asset and internal fleet support in transportation management, Trimble stands out as a top choice for shippers and third-party logistics providers (3PLs). With a strong focus on the North American market, Trimble offers robust solutions that cater to the unique needs of this region.

Trimble’s Transportation Management System (TMS) is designed to optimize non-asset transportation operations, providing companies with the tools they need to effectively manage their internal fleets. By utilizing Trimble’s TMS, businesses can streamline their transportation processes, improve visibility, and enhance operational efficiency.

With Trimble’s North American focus, their TMS is specifically tailored to meet the requirements of the region’s transportation industry. This localized expertise allows Trimble to understand the nuances and challenges faced by companies operating in North America, providing solutions that are relevant and effective in this market.

By leveraging Trimble’s TMS, shippers and 3PLs can achieve better control over their transportation activities, reduce operational costs, and enhance customer satisfaction. Trimble’s commitment to delivering high-quality solutions and comprehensive support makes them a trusted partner for businesses seeking top-notch transportation management services.

  • Optimize non-asset and internal fleet operations
  • Streamline transportation processes
  • Improve visibility and tracking capabilities
  • Enhance operational efficiency
  • Reduce transportation costs
  • Ensure on-time deliveries

Trimble’s TMS is a valuable asset for companies looking to maximize their transportation management capabilities in the North American market. With its focus on non-asset and internal fleet support, Trimble offers tailored solutions that deliver real results for businesses operating in this region.

Uber Freight TMS (formerly Transplace)

Uber Freight TMS, formerly known as Transplace, initially gained popularity for its managed TM option. However, it has been quickly expanding its TMS as a standalone platform. It offers both North American and international capabilities through partnerships. The reported TCO is relatively competitive. Its customer base includes medium to large shippers.

Features Benefits
Managed TM option Allows businesses to outsource transportation management, freeing up resources and reducing operational costs.
North American and international capabilities Enables businesses to manage their transportation needs both domestically and globally, ensuring efficient supply chain operations.
Competitive TCO Provides cost-effective transportation management solutions without compromising on quality and functionality.
Medium to large shippers Serves a wide range of businesses, catering to their specific transportation requirements and scaling with their growth.

Creating a Suitable TMS Requirements Document

When selecting a Transportation Management System (TMS), it is crucial for businesses to create a comprehensive requirements document. This document serves as a guide for evaluating potential solutions and ensuring an objective decision-making process.

The TMS requirements document should include specific criteria and ratings for each requirement based on its importance to the company. By assigning ratings, such as high, medium, or low, businesses can prioritize their needs and focus on the most critical aspects of the system.

One important consideration when evaluating TMS providers is their ability to customize the software to fit the specific needs of the business. This customization allows for a tailored solution that aligns with the company’s unique processes and requirements. When creating the requirements document, it is essential to evaluate the software provider’s customization capabilities and understand the associated costs.

Another aspect to consider is the integration of custom code into the base code of the TMS. This allows businesses to further customize and enhance the system to meet their specific needs. Understanding the level of customization and integration capabilities is crucial for long-term successful utilization of the chosen TMS.

Benefits of a Comprehensive TMS Requirements Document

By creating a thorough TMS requirements document, businesses can ensure an objective decision-making process. This document serves as a reference point during the evaluation and selection of TMS providers, providing clarity on the system’s capabilities and addressing specific business requirements. It also helps in comparing different providers and selecting the one that best meets the company’s needs.

A well-defined requirements document facilitates effective communication between the business and the TMS provider. It helps both parties understand the expectations and goals, leading to the successful implementation of the chosen TMS. Additionally, a comprehensive document reduces the risk of misunderstandings and minimizes the need for costly modifications or customizations after implementation.

A well-defined requirements document facilitates effective communication between the business and the TMS provider, ensuring a successful implementation of the chosen TMS.

Creating a TMS requirements document is a critical step in the selection process. It allows businesses to evaluate TMS providers objectively, simplify the decision-making process, and ensure the chosen solution aligns with their specific needs and objectives. By considering customization capabilities, integration of custom code, and overall alignment with requirements, businesses can establish a solid foundation for a long-term successful relationship with their chosen TMS provider.

Benefits of a Comprehensive TMS Requirements Document
Objective decision-making process
Clear evaluation criteria and priorities
Effective communication with TMS providers
Minimizes the need for costly modifications post-implementation

Conclusion

In conclusion, when it comes to finding the best Transportation Management solution for your business, thorough evaluation is key. Factors such as the size of your company, specific requirements, budget, and long-term goals should be carefully considered. Fortunately, the transportation software market offers a variety of reliable and efficient options to choose from.

Some of the top Transportation Management providers in the market include e2open, Descartes, Blue Yonder, Manhattan, MercuryGate, Oracle, SAP, TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson, Trimble, and Uber Freight TMS. These companies have established themselves as industry leaders, providing comprehensive solutions for businesses of all sizes.

To ensure a successful TMS implementation process, it is crucial to create a detailed requirements document. This document should outline specific criteria and ratings for each requirement, based on their importance to your company. Additionally, consider the software provider’s ability to customize the system according to your needs, the cost of customization, and the integration of custom code into the base code.

By carefully evaluating these factors and considering the top Transportation Management providers, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your transportation management needs. Implementing the right TMS will not only streamline your logistics operations but also drive cost savings and enhance customer satisfaction, ultimately benefiting your business in the long run.

FAQ

What is a Transportation Management System (TMS)?

A Transportation Management System (TMS) is a software solution that helps businesses efficiently manage and optimize their transportation operations. It includes features such as planning, execution, tracking, and settlement of shipments, providing a streamlined supply chain and improved customer satisfaction.

Why should businesses use a Transportation Management System (TMS)?

Businesses should use a TMS to improve their logistics operations, reduce costs, and enhance customer satisfaction. A TMS helps streamline the supply chain process, ensuring efficient planning, execution, and tracking of shipments, leading to increased operational efficiency and better decision-making.

What are the top Transportation Management System providers?

Some of the top Transportation Management System providers include e2open, Descartes, Blue Yonder, Manhattan, MercuryGate, Oracle, SAP, TMC – A Division of C.H. Robinson, Trimble, and Uber Freight TMS. These providers offer reliable and affordable solutions for businesses of all sizes.

What features and capabilities do these providers offer?

These providers offer comprehensive transportation management solutions, catering to all modes and regions of transportation. They provide robust capabilities for domestic and international freight, catering to shippers, freight forwarders, carriers, and logistics service providers. Additionally, they integrate well with other supply chain and enterprise resource planning (ERP) software.

How do I select the best Transportation Management solution for my business?

To select the best Transportation Management solution for your business, it is crucial to consider factors such as company size, specific requirements, budget, and long-term goals. It is recommended to create a detailed requirements document that includes specific criteria and ratings for each requirement based on its importance to your company.

Does customization play a role in selecting a Transportation Management System?

Yes, customization is an important factor to consider when selecting a Transportation Management System. A comprehensive requirements document will help evaluate the software provider’s ability to customize the system according to your specific needs. It is also crucial to consider the cost of customization and the integration of custom code into the base code.

Source Links

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Reddit
Pinterest

Table of Contents

Recent Post